Even Given the Worthless Appraiser Class Im Actually the Strongest [Season 1 Episode 11]

Review: Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest – Season 1, Episode 11

A Rollercoaster of Expectations and Execution

Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest (or Fuguushoku “Kanteishi” ga Jitsu wa Saikyou Datta for the purists) is one of those anime that starts with a premise so intriguing, you can’t help but dive in. The story follows Ein, a guy stuck with the “Appraiser” class in a world where your god-given job defines your worth. Naturally, being an appraiser sucks—until Ein discovers his class is secretly OP. Cue the power fantasy!

Episode 11 continues Ein’s journey, but the reactions from fans are… mixed, to say the least. Let’s break it down.

The Good: Power Fantasy Done (Mostly) Right

First, the positives. The show nails the underdog-to-overpowered trope that fans of The Rising of the Shield Hero or Arifureta will recognize. Ein’s growth from a discarded nobody to a powerhouse is satisfying, especially when he flexes his appraisal skills in creative ways.

Fans on MyAnimeList and Reddit have pointed out that Episode 11 delivers some solid action. Ein’s ability to analyze and counter enemies feels fresh compared to brute-force protagonists. One user noted:

“Wow, this will be an amazing show if they can pull off using appraisal skills to defeat monsters.”

And honestly? They kinda do. Watching Ein outsmart foes with his enhanced eye (courtesy of Yuri, the tree spirit) is a highlight.

Another plus? The humor. The dynamic between Ein and his growing harem (because of course there’s a harem) is lighthearted and fun. Ursula, the tree guardian, steals scenes with her no-nonsense attitude, and Yuri’s innocence adds charm.

The Bad: Whiplash Pacing and Forgotten Stakes

Now, the criticisms. The biggest gripe from fans? The show’s tonal whiplash.

The first episode set up a dark, almost tragic backstory—Ein betrayed, left to die, and driven to suicide. But by Episode 11, that trauma is… barely mentioned. One fan put it bluntly:

“They spent an entire episode making him look like a pathetic bullied rag who gave up on life… and then he just moves on like nothing happened?”

It’s jarring. The show pivots from revenge drama to lighthearted adventure so fast, you’d think Ein got a personality reset.

Another issue? The pacing. Episode 11 crams in new characters, power-ups, and plot twists like it’s racing to the finish line. A Reddit user joked:

“This feels like they speedran 25 chapters of the manga in one episode.”

And they’re not wrong. The rapid-fire introductions of new tree spirits (each with their own quirks) make the world feel overcrowded rather than immersive.

The Ugly: Overpowered to a Fault

Let’s talk power scaling. Ein’s abilities are cool, but by Episode 11, he’s bordering on In Another World With My Smartphone levels of OP. Some fans are frustrated:

“They gave him way too many tools and empowered him too easily. There’s no challenge anymore.”

The lack of stakes is a problem. When Ein can analyze, counter, and absorb abilities with minimal effort, fights lose tension. Compare this to Shield Hero, where Naofumi’s limitations forced creativity. Here, Ein’s growth feels unearned.

And don’t get fans started on Zoid, the former party member who betrayed Ein. His redemption (or lack thereof) is divisive:

“So Zoid murdered people and just… walks away? What kind of justice is that?”

It’s a missed opportunity for deeper conflict.

Final Verdict: Fun, But Flawed

Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest is a mixed bag. Episode 11 delivers action and humor, but struggles with pacing, tone, and stakes.

For fans of power fantasies, it’s a decent watch—just don’t expect depth. As one reviewer summed it up:

“It’s like junk food. Tasty in the moment, but you won’t remember it tomorrow.”

Rating: 6.5/10 – A fun ride, but don’t think too hard about it.

What did you think of Episode 11? Did Ein’s power-ups feel earned, or was it too much too fast? Drop your thoughts below!