Kusuriya no Hitorigoto [Season 1 Episode 39]

Episode 39 Review: Kusuriya no Hitorigoto – A Masterclass in Subtle Storytelling

If there’s one thing Kusuriya no Hitorigoto (also known as The Apothecary Diaries) has consistently delivered, it’s a blend of mystery, wit, and emotional depth that keeps fans hooked. Episode 39, titled “The Ice Beneath the Surface,” is no exception. Directed by Norihiro Naganuma and produced by TOHO Animation and OLM, this episode continues the series’ tradition of weaving intricate narratives with Maomao’s sharp intellect at the center.

Plot Summary: A Cold Case Heats Up

The episode opens with Maomao, the brilliant but eccentric apothecary, investigating a peculiar case involving poisoned ice—yes, you read that right. In a world where even frozen water can be deadly, Maomao’s deductive skills are put to the test. The ice, supposedly harvested under “ideal conditions,” turns out to be anything but harmless. As she digs deeper, the episode unravels layers of palace intrigue, personal vendettas, and a surprising connection to Jinshi’s past.

What makes this episode stand out is its pacing. Unlike some previous episodes that leaned heavily on dialogue, Episode 39 balances exposition with visual storytelling. The scenes where Maomao examines the ice under candlelight are eerily beautiful, showcasing the anime’s attention to detail. Meanwhile, Jinshi’s rare moments of vulnerability add emotional weight, reminding us that even the most composed characters have cracks in their armor.

Fan Reactions: Split Opinions, But Mostly Praise

Over on MyAnimeList, fans are buzzing about the episode’s tonal shift. Some viewers loved the darker, more serious atmosphere, calling it a refreshing change from the usual lighthearted banter. One user, AnimeLover42, wrote:

“This episode felt like a return to the show’s roots—mystery first, humor second. Maomao’s deductions were on point, and that final reveal? Chills.”

Others, however, missed the playful dynamic between Maomao and Jinshi. ChibiCritic commented:

“I get that the plot needed to be serious, but where was the usual sass? Even Maomao seemed too subdued here.”

The debate highlights the show’s ability to cater to different tastes—whether you’re here for the puzzles or the character interactions, Kusuriya no Hitorigoto delivers.

Animation & Soundtrack: A Feast for the Senses

The animation quality remains stellar, with TOHO Animation flexing its skills in subtle ways. The way light refracts through the poisoned ice, the flicker of candle flames, and even the texture of Maomao’s robes—every frame feels meticulously crafted. The soundtrack, composed by Kevin Penkin (yes, the genius behind Made in Abyss), complements the tension perfectly. The use of sparse, haunting strings during the investigation scenes adds an almost cinematic quality.

Final Verdict: Another Win for the Series

Episode 39 might not be the flashiest installment, but it’s a testament to why Kusuriya no Hitorigoto has such a dedicated fanbase. It’s smart, visually stunning, and unafraid to take risks with its storytelling. If you’re a fan of mysteries with a historical twist, this episode is a must-watch.

Rating: 9/10 – A near-perfect blend of intrigue and emotion, though a tad more Maomao sass would’ve been the cherry on top.

What did you think of the episode? Drop your thoughts in the comments—let’s geek out together!

P.S. If you haven’t caught up yet, the entire series is streaming on Anime Nexus with English subs. Trust me, it’s worth the binge.