Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest [Season 1 Episode 1 to Episode 12]

“Even Given the Worthless ‘Appraiser’ Class, I’m Actually the Strongest” – A Rollercoaster of Power and Tone Shifts

Introduction

The anime Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest (also known by its Japanese title Fuguushoku “Kanteishi” ga Jitsu wa Saikyou Datta) is a fantasy isekai that dives into the life of Ein, a young man cursed with the “Appraiser” class—a job deemed utterly useless in a world where divine-given roles dictate one’s worth. The show starts with a dark, almost tragic tone but quickly pivots into a power fantasy, leaving fans divided.

The Premise and Early Episodes

The first episode sets up Ein as a pitiable underdog. His party, consisting of the arrogant Zoid and Jolene, treats him like expendable bait. When they’re ambushed by monsters, Zoid abandons Ein to die, pushing him to the brink of despair. In a moment of hopelessness, Ein chooses to jump off a cliff rather than face a gruesome death—only to be saved by Yuri, the spirit of the World Tree, and her guardian, Ursula.

This is where the show takes a sharp turn. Yuri grants Ein the “Spirit Eye,” which supercharges his Appraiser abilities, turning him into an overpowered protagonist almost overnight. Fans on MyAnimeList and Reddit have mixed feelings about this shift. Some appreciate the fast-paced power-up, while others feel it undermines the emotional weight of Ein’s initial struggles.

Fan Reactions: Love It or Hate It?

1. The Tone Shift Whiplash
   Many viewers, like @runec, pointed out the jarring transition from a dark, revenge-driven narrative to a lighthearted harem adventure. The first episode paints Ein as a broken character, but by Episode 2, he’s training with Ursula, cracking jokes, and flirting with Yuri. Some fans, like @Jozuwa-_-, argue that the show abandons its initial themes too quickly, making Ein’s trauma feel inconsequential.

2. The Power Fantasy Debate
   Ein’s rapid ascension to godlike status has sparked debates. Some fans, like @MenchiK1, enjoy the wish-fulfillment aspect, arguing that not every protagonist needs to be fueled by revenge. Others, like @HOOfan_1, criticize the lack of creative limitations—Ein’s Appraiser skills are quickly overshadowed by his new abilities, making the premise feel like a bait-and-switch.

3. The Harem Element
   By Episode 3, Ein’s journey shifts toward collecting “tree waifus,” as fans jokingly call them. The introduction of new female characters, like the princess he saves, feels rushed. @zkeleton notes that the show prioritizes quantity over depth, cramming too many plot points into single episodes.

Strengths and Weaknesses

• Pros:
• Ursula’s Banter: Many fans agree that Ursula’s dynamic with Ein is a highlight. Her tough-love training and sarcastic remarks add humor.
• Unique Skill Concept: The idea of an “Appraiser” becoming powerful is intriguing, even if the execution falters.

• Visuals and Action: The animation quality, especially during fight scenes, keeps the show engaging.

• Cons:

• Pacing Issues: The show rushes through character arcs, like Zoid’s redemption (or lack thereof), leaving fans unsatisfied.
• Lack of Stakes: Ein’s overpowered nature removes tension. As @marklebid puts it, “They might as well declare him a god now.”
• Inconsistent Themes: The shift from despair to wish-fulfillment feels unearned, making the narrative feel disjointed.

Final Verdict

Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest is a mixed bag. It starts with a compelling underdog story but quickly devolves into a generic power fantasy with harem elements. If you’re looking for a light, fast-paced anime with overpowered protagonists and quirky side characters, this might entertain you. But if you prefer deeper character development and consistent storytelling, you might find it frustrating.

As @MenchiK1 aptly summarizes: “This isn’t a revenge story—it’s a second-chance story.” Whether that’s a good or bad thing depends on what you’re looking for.

Rating: 6.5/10 – Fun but flawed.

Would you give it a shot, or is this another drop for you? Let me know in the comments!